Jidaigeki Special: Shingo's 10 Duels (新吾十番勝負) (Japan, 1990) [TV] – 2/5
An underwhelming TV movie based on the same novel as the famous late 50s/early 60s theatrical series. Those films were essentially disposable programmers, yet filmed with a staggering amount of style and professionalism that existed in studio cinema back then. This 2½ hour small screen version in contrast was shot on video, without a single inspired frame or cut. It even pales in comparison to TV jidaigeki shows from less than a decade before, when they still used to shoot on film. It's quite a shame really, as this is packed with talent from the old days, from co-screenwriter Norifumi Suzuki to composer Shunsuke Kikuchi and a star studded cast featuring Hiroyuki Sanada, Sonny Chiba, Tomisaburo Wakayama and Yoshiko Sakuma. The big name cast, and the brief bits of action featuring Sanada, Chiba and Wakayama, are the highlights. Sadly no one seems be doing more than the bare minimum of what was expected of them. The classic storyline still works somewhat, though amusingly it seems a little censored in places – and this is compared to the movies made in the 1950s!
Peonies and Dragons (牡丹と竜) (Japan, 1970) [35mm] – 3/5
Masahiro Makino remakes his own Toei film Tales of Japanese Chivalry: Attack from 1967. This Nikkatsu version has quite a different flavour, trading chivalrous Ken Takakura for a more temperamental Hideki Takahashi, who plays a single father yakuza trying to make an honest living with an honourable tekiya gang. They are being harassed by Toru Abe’s scumbag yakuza gang who want their share of the market. This is a refreshing change from the usual stoic, low-key ninkyo hero narratives (the premise and tone somewhat resemble Sonny Chiba’s Game of Chance trilogy at Toei, also a bit of an outlier in the genre). A particular highlight is Akira Kobayashi as a flamboyant comrade. He also sings the film’s theme song, which sounds more like a youthful pop song than the kind of old fashioned enka tune that could be expected, and gives an interesting twist to the film’s ninkyo march scene. That being said, this film still follows the repressed ninkyo hero formula, and is even sparser on action than most films of its kind. Director Makino often seemed more interested in period and human drama than action. This one works quite well regardless, with a bit of a different flavour added to the usual recipe.
