Page 2 of 2

Posted: 28 Dec 2005, 21:14
by bradavon
I've split up the Scart and HD Talk into it's own thread here:

https://www.bulletsnbabesdvd.com/forums/ ... php?t=1298

Posted: 28 Dec 2005, 22:39
by romerojpg
I watched Eraser the other night! wow I forgot how good it was! I am currently writing a nice favorable review of it, as its bloody great! nice, mindless violence and one liners its classic and its aged perfectly.

Posted: 28 Dec 2005, 23:32
by bradavon
How does it compare to True Lies?

I've not seen Eraser for years. I remember it being enjoyable but not a keeper.

Posted: 29 Dec 2005, 00:54
by Markgway
I enjoyed True Lies when I saw it at the cinema, but even though I have the DVD, I must admit it's overlong and gets bogged down with misogyny and smugness in the second third. Great action scenes though... and Arnie. 8)

Posted: 29 Dec 2005, 01:15
by gasteropod
I own the heavily cut R2 of this film. I quite like it as a typical Arnie action film, but I can't really watch it anymore due to the 3.5 minutes of action cut out of it.

Posted: 28 Jan 2006, 22:22
by saltysam
this is dirt cheap at dvdpacific and you get collateral damage thrown in as a bonus!

http://www.dvdpacific.com/item.asp?ID=700232

Posted: 30 Jan 2006, 10:38
by gojensen
Tom, Pitch correction doesn't always mean the sound is OK. Because they DO need to "mess" with the sound... look at The FellowShip of the Ring R2... the soundtrack on it is not good.

As for Resolution, there's 96 more lines of picture on PAL, but honestly on my system NTSC looks better (this is related to my scaler which seems to do 480 upscaling better than 576 upscaling)... and the difference between PAL and NTSC doesn't seem that big with anamorphic video as it does with non-anamorphic video.

of course, this is all depending on your viewing distance, if you are borderline close to your set with PAL, you would notice scanlines when switching to NTSC (on a regular CRT/tube TV).

As for this PAL/NTSC... when going HD they had every chance in the world to make a multisync standard... think how nice it would be to have a 96 or 72 fps HD screen? (Those are multiples of 24 - meaning no conversion needed for film material!)...

One could scream!

As for ERASER... I have the old NTSC LaserDisc... Do I need to upgrade? Let's see... when did I last see this flick... :lol:

Posted: 01 Feb 2006, 13:52
by EvaUnit02
Markgway wrote:I enjoyed True Lies when I saw it at the cinema, but even though I have the DVD, I must admit it's overlong and gets bogged down with misogyny and smugness in the second third. Great action scenes though... and Arnie. 8)
I enjoyed all the comedy stuff with Jamie Lee Curtis and Bill Paxton.
. Great action scenes though... and Arnie. 8)
Couldn't agree more. Cameron sure knows how to craft some fucking fantastic action scenes.

*Arnie in Harrier to head baddy sitting on missile*
"You're fired!" *Arnie fires missile, head baddy goes boom*:D

Posted: 06 Feb 2006, 18:10
by grim_tales
Its' very cheap now ($AUS15) at Ezy. R4 Eraser should be about 110 mins long (PAL) right? I'll get the R4 as I dont like silver platter discs.

Posted: 06 Feb 2006, 18:38
by grim_tales
Are you sure R4 is a amaray? All the old R4 reviews I've read say its a snapper.

Also basically I'm confused as to what the original runtime was - one R4 review says its 109m 52s, but add 3m 22s to 106m 58s (the length of the 15 video) and you get 110m 20s :?

t also says the "Film" 18 version ran 109m 10s before being submitted to the BBFC - eh?

Posted: 07 Feb 2006, 01:48
by Markgway
Some of the BBFC cuts were substitutions; that would affect the run time.

Posted: 07 Feb 2006, 08:45
by grim_tales
Hmm. If you take away 28s from 3m 22s, you get 2:54, which is the exact difference between the 15 version and the Australian DVD. Maybe the cinema cuts don't apply for the R4?

Posted: 07 Feb 2006, 18:35
by grim_tales
I'm confused. Whats' annoying is my player doesnt show what the exact runtime of a DVD is when you pop it in the player (my old one did). There are other European versions I could buy though.

Posted: 07 Feb 2006, 19:09
by Markgway
Er, I've already explained the time discrepancy Grim. Did you see my last post? :?

Posted: 07 Feb 2006, 19:51
by grim_tales
Sorry, didnt realise that. The BBFC site doesn't say that.
All non UK DVDs (and r4) must be uncut then. :)

Posted: 08 Feb 2006, 01:40
by Markgway
grim_tales wrote:Sorry, didnt realise that. The BBFC site doesn't say that.
I checked the BBFC listing and you're right there's no mention to substituted cuts, but having seen the full cuts list, and compared three versions myself (hey, I was bored) I can assure you that only about 2:45 of actual footage has been cut, the rest of the 3:22 cut time is due to the rearrangement of footage to accomodate substantial re-editing. This is most noticeable in the butchered VHS take on the raid on the cabin in the woods. It's incoherent on tape. we're supposed to find out at this point James Caan is the villain, but the removal of his smothering of the witness robs us of this important plot point! It's now a little while later when Caan shoots the kid on the plane we learn what he is. I would assume that every non-UK version is uncut unless you hear otherwise. I have the R1.

Posted: 08 Feb 2006, 08:46
by grim_tales
OK, cheers Mark :D I'll get the r4 :)

Posted: 08 Feb 2006, 14:25
by grim_tales
Brad do Atlantic DVD charge on order or when they ship?

Re: Eraser (Schwarzanegger) - best version?

Posted: 06 Apr 2010, 21:44
by saltysam
To update this thread,the best version is now the uncut usa BD.

Re: Eraser (Schwarzanegger) - best version?

Posted: 07 Apr 2010, 04:58
by Markgway
I have it. Good film, sags a little in the middle, but the first and third acts are top-notch. Was passed uncut by the BBFC, but a BD never came.