Page 2 of 3

Posted: 16 Feb 2007, 16:53
by Killer Meteor
If there's a supplier who let's you return said item because the sound is bad, that'd be good. What's HKFlix like in that field?

Posted: 16 Feb 2007, 19:31
by thelostdragon
Ivan Drago wrote:Don't know. I don't feel like taking the risk at the moment
We wouldn't have such a decent "Rocky IV" if the real Ivan Drago didn't feel like taking risks.

Posted: 16 Feb 2007, 22:49
by Markgway
thelostdragon wrote:We wouldn't have such a decent "Rocky IV" if the real Ivan Drago didn't feel like taking risks.
You mean he's not the real Drago?

Say it ain't so...

Posted: 16 Feb 2007, 23:19
by Killer Meteor
Hey, you try getting along in the world without Communism and stereoids. God, I miss the 80's

Posted: 19 Feb 2007, 03:25
by DangerousLeeHandsome
Finally watched DD's PS2 and comparing to my IVL disc, the image looks damn near identical. I actually think DD's looks a bit better than IVL's as far as contrast levels and sharpness goes. There is a bit of grain here and there, but certainly nothing as bothersome as PS1. Though I do notice the pinkifying in the screencaps here, its not quite as bad as some people claim. Besides, JC's face is always pink anyways LOL! Bottom line: DD's PS2 is a solid release.

Posted: 19 Feb 2007, 03:58
by Markgway
Solid as jelly.

Posted: 19 Feb 2007, 09:00
by Killer Meteor
It's funny. It seems for once Harvey has a good agenda in releasing uncut versions in the original language. It's just he hired some clowns for the restoration team. The irony of it all!

Posted: 19 Feb 2007, 23:35
by RickyTheDragonSteamboat
Markgway wrote:Solid as jelly.
Umm...okay. HKL's was crap. I say stick with DD or IVL's. They're almost the same.

Posted: 19 Feb 2007, 23:41
by Markgway
At least HKL used the original theatrical version.

I suppose that's the one good thing I can say about it.

Posted: 19 Feb 2007, 23:52
by Killer Meteor
Is there the option to here the PS2 theme song on the DD DVD? That's the only reason I've held onto my HKL

Posted: 20 Feb 2007, 00:23
by DangerousLeeHandsome
Markgway wrote:At least HKL used the original theatrical version.

I suppose that's the one good thing I can say about it.
I personally prefer the shorter cut too. I think FS went with the longer Japanese version simply because it was better preserved than the domestic HK version. Or something like that.

Posted: 20 Feb 2007, 00:58
by Markgway
I'm sure it's because that's what Fortune Star gave them.

If DD insisted on the theatrical cut then FS would have had to go back and create a new HD master for it.

Not like DD couldn't afford it, mind.

Posted: 20 Feb 2007, 02:06
by DangerousLeeHandsome
Most of the fans (not all) are always demading longer cuts of these films so I guess FS felt they did the fans a favor by putting out a longer cut.

Posted: 20 Feb 2007, 11:37
by chenlung
FS wrongly did the Japanese version anyway, they got the incorrect ending.

They do have the HK version in a non-remastered form. I'm sure having 2 versions would be appealing so I'm guessing they wouldn't have a problem.

I can always ask Peter Poon.

Posted: 20 Feb 2007, 11:45
by grim_tales
How does the Japanese version really end?
AFAIK the FS "Japanese version" has the Police Story theme over the credits (instead of the other song) plus a different set of outtakes :?

Well...

Posted: 20 Feb 2007, 12:33
by chenlung
grim_tales wrote:How does the Japanese version really end?
AFAIK the FS "Japanese version" has the Police Story theme over the credits (instead of the other song) plus a different set of outtakes :?
I believe it uses the HK ending. Can't be sure, so can anyone confirm?

Posted: 20 Feb 2007, 14:38
by grim_tales
Now you mention it I'm sure it uses that ending (with Maggie and Jackie admiring the fireworks).

Posted: 20 Feb 2007, 17:29
by Markgway
grim_tales wrote:AFAIK the FS "Japanese version" has the Police Story theme over the credits (instead of the other song) plus a different set of outtakes :?
Exactly right.

Posted: 20 Feb 2007, 22:39
by chenlung
What outtakes?

Posted: 21 Feb 2007, 23:56
by captainjoe
Easily the IVL wins. It's the perfect balance between the two other transfers.

Posted: 22 Feb 2007, 00:02
by Killer Meteor
Yeah, but the sound...

Posted: 22 Feb 2007, 00:05
by captainjoe
Ivan Drago wrote:Yeah, but the sound...
Well except for that. :lol:

Re: Police Story 2 HKL R2 vs Dragon Dynasty R1 vs IVL

Posted: 08 Mar 2014, 12:04
by Beat TG
There's a new custom of the theatrical cut at ADC. Video source is from the HK BD, original audio mix from an old VHS that apparently has clitches that the uploader tried to fix but only few remain, and the subs from HKL DVD.

I'm thinking of getting it but is there a difference on the subtitles between HKL and DD?

Re: Police Story 2 HKL R2 vs Dragon Dynasty R1 vs IVL

Posted: 08 Mar 2014, 14:46
by Markgway
Sounds good in theory... but without seeing/hearing the finished result the quality of the fan editing remains an unknown quantity.

Funnily enough I have a rip of the IVL DVD and was thinking of trying something similar myself. This may have saved me the bother.

Let us know how it plays...

Re: Police Story 2 HKL R2 vs Dragon Dynasty R1 vs IVL

Posted: 01 Apr 2014, 23:57
by Killer Meteor
Christ, that HKL disc was a disaster. We sure put up with a lot from HKL in 2002 - not even Fortune Star would pull those kind of monkey shines these days.