Re: The off-topic topic
Posted: 11 Feb 2011, 16:28
"Oniichan... can I suck your cock?"
OK, I just made that one up.
OK, I just made that one up.
gasteropod wrote:That's very creepy
Mark just managed to be more creepyMarkgway wrote:"Oniichan... can I suck your cock?"
HungFist wrote:Mark just managed to be more creepy
I am asian.HungFist wrote:The interesting thing with original Japanese stuff is that it tends to bring the worst out of foreigners. You can hardly show a film with girls wearing school uniforms without foreign viewers getting instant paedophilic thoughs, usually disguised as critisism...![]()
Whoa, lucky me I used the word "foreigner" and not "westerner". Almost got onwed herebrooce-leroy wrote:I am asian.HungFist wrote:The interesting thing with original Japanese stuff is that it tends to bring the worst out of foreigners. You can hardly show a film with girls wearing school uniforms without foreign viewers getting instant paedophilic thoughs, usually disguised as critisism...![]()
My father and mother are from China and Malaysia respectively.HungFist wrote:Whoa, lucky me I used the word "foreigner" and not "westerner". Almost got onwed herebrooce-leroy wrote:I am asian.HungFist wrote:The interesting thing with original Japanese stuff is that it tends to bring the worst out of foreigners. You can hardly show a film with girls wearing school uniforms without foreign viewers getting instant paedophilic thoughs, usually disguised as critisism...![]()
![]()
Where you from?
A bit like my ex-girlfriend then. One day she was Japanese, the next day Chinese, which ever suited her bestbrooce-leroy wrote:My father and mother are from China and Malaysia respectively.I was born in the UK so am sort of a westerner depending on how you look at it.
Yup, coz it's us foreigners and not the japanese who have a problem with adult men paying schoolkids for sex......HungFist wrote:The interesting thing with original Japanese stuff is that it tends to bring the worst out of foreigners. You can hardly show a film with girls wearing school uniforms without foreign viewers getting instant paedophilic thoughs, usually disguised as critisism...![]()
hehe, it's a creepy product for sure. But I can see it also (as in in addition to) as an innocent part of otaku culture. Some people keep cute cats, some (had) tamagochi, some teddy bear (in fact, everyone in Japan adores teddy bears). I could actually easily label this dvd in the same category. That's not to say it doesn't (intentionally) fall to "other" categories as wellShingster wrote:Yup, coz it's us foreigners and not the japanese who have a problem with adult men paying schoolkids for sex......HungFist wrote:The interesting thing with original Japanese stuff is that it tends to bring the worst out of foreigners. You can hardly show a film with girls wearing school uniforms without foreign viewers getting instant paedophilic thoughs, usually disguised as critisism...![]()
Saying that though, I have a friend who thinks Totoro is perverted because you can see Mei's nappy when she's running around the countryside!
Well they're a drongo then, Totoro is the most charming film I've ever seenShingster wrote:I have a friend who thinks Totoro is perverted because you can see Mei's nappy when she's running around the countryside!
Like we all haven't slept with our sisters...? Just the other day my little sis (she's 15) crawled into my bed and asked for a rubdown. No harm in that.brooce-leroy wrote:whats all this big brother, can i sleep with you stuff?
I did find that a bit creepy... if only because there wasn't a sufficient context. It was just a grown man touching a child's penis for no reason. Maybe nothing sick... but a bit 'off' to say the least.brooce-leroy wrote:Talking about this paedophiliac association in movies, a lot of people have a problem with Stephen Chow flicking a child's penis in King of Comedy. Whilst it is completely "out there" in terms of doing it for humour, when I first watched the movie, it never ever occurred to me that there was anything sinister about it. Maybe its some sort of cultural thing, but to me, it is an innocent scene, and I never thought any more about it. I didn't know that anything more was made about it until I read stuff on the net.
Of course it's totally innocent and a genuinely alarming and laugh-out-loud visual gag (iirc he doesn't actually touch the boy himself does he? He uses a twig?), and if anyone has even the remotest bit of problem with that shot.... well, it says much more about their own warped mindset than the people who took the scene for what it is. The boy is too young to be sexually aroused by what Chow is doing and there is clearly no sexual intent on Chow's part at all. It's absolutely no different to if he was flicking the child's nose ffs.brooce-leroy wrote:Talking about this paedophiliac association in movies, a lot of people have a problem with Stephen Chow flicking a child's penis in King of Comedy. Whilst it is completely "out there" in terms of doing it for humour, when I first watched the movie, it never ever occurred to me that there was anything sinister about it. Maybe its some sort of cultural thing, but to me, it is an innocent scene, and I never thought any more about it. I didn't know that anything more was made about it until I read stuff on the net.
I'm gonna chalk that statement up to you probably not finding the right term in English to use here, as the idea that Totoro is bringing up any kind of sexualised thoughts in Westerners like my friend is utterly ridiculous. The attitude of my friend, and many of the westerners out there, who have problems with scenes like the bathing scene in Totoro has nothing to do with any deep-rooted paedophilic tendencies in themeselves and everything to do with the plain old ignorance and arrogance of us British people: Ignorance of another culture that may view communal bathing or the site of a child in nappies as a completely innocent thing, and the arrogant certainty that their own narrow values are the the "correct" or less morally dubious ones.HungFist wrote:However, what disturbs me more than some japanese otaku and beyond products is the instant paedophile alarm that they cause in the west. Your friend is an example. No offence to him, but I get seriously worried when sexual thoughts pop up in someone's head when they see Totoro. It's amazing how easy it seems to be to make a "westerner" have "paedophilic thoughs", even if they are "critical thoughts".
Yes, it is a cultural and ignorance related thing. But the outcome is still the same: someone is watching Totoro and somehow manages to question whether what he is seeing is right or wrong (I didn't mean paedophilic tendencies, the word choise was a bit provocative and inaccurate, and in quotation marks for that reason). But such questions shouldn't come to your mind in the first place. If you see a naked kid, and your first reaction is "Paedophile Warning, Ban that sick movie!"... well, that's what disturbs me.Shingster wrote:I'm gonna chalk that statement up to you probably not finding the right term in English to use here, as the idea that Totoro is bringing up any kind of sexualised thoughts in Westerners like my friend is utterly ridiculous. The attitude of my friend, and many of the westerners out there, who have problems with scenes like the bathing scene in Totoro has nothing to do with any deep-rooted paedophilic tendencies in themeselves and everything to do with the plain old ignorance and arrogance of us British people: Ignorance of another culture that may view communal bathing or the site of a child in nappies as a completely innocent thing, and the arrogant certainty that their own narrow values are the the "correct" or less morally dubious ones.HungFist wrote:However, what disturbs me more than some japanese otaku and beyond products is the instant paedophile alarm that they cause in the west. Your friend is an example. No offence to him, but I get seriously worried when sexual thoughts pop up in someone's head when they see Totoro. It's amazing how easy it seems to be to make a "westerner" have "paedophilic thoughs", even if they are "critical thoughts".
Ah, sorry. That was me.saltysam wrote:Wow..Christophe Gans just bought a dvd off me.
Woah... seems like Mr Gans enjoys jumping to conclusions....saltysam wrote:He bought an old Sherlock Holmes dvd from me.when i saw his name and then his address i messaged him and asked was it the same Mr Gans who made Crying Freeman & Brotherhood Of The Wolf...he replied saying "glad you enjoyed my work"
Yi-Long wrote:Woah... seems like Mr Gans enjoys jumping to conclusions....saltysam wrote:He bought an old Sherlock Holmes dvd from me.when i saw his name and then his address i messaged him and asked was it the same Mr Gans who made Crying Freeman & Brotherhood Of The Wolf...he replied saying "glad you enjoyed my work"