Page 1 of 1
007: Octopussy - UK R2 (SE) vs UK R2 (UE)
Posted: 17 Jul 2006, 23:17
by MLAM
New set of Comparison's anyone who wants to throw in some R1 captures if they have any then feel free.
R2 Special Edition
R2 Ultimate Edition
R2 Special Edition
R2 Ultimate Edition
R2 Special Edition
R2 Ultimate Edition
R2 Special Edition
R2 Ultimate Edition
R2 Special Edition
R2 Ultimate Edition
R2 Special Edition
R2 Ultimate Edition
R2 Special Edition
R2 Ultimate Edition
R2 Special Edition
R2 Ultimate Edition

Posted: 17 Jul 2006, 23:34
by bradavon
Now that's what I'm talking about, the UE looks much better. Photo 3 is lovely 8)
MLAM: Any of adding a "The World is Not Enough" DVD Comparison please? I can add the UK R2 SE if you like.
Posted: 18 Jul 2006, 00:03
by Markgway
I never bought the R1 as it's the same version as the R2.
The captions/subs are missing from the UE though, right? I can't remember if they were on the SE as generated text.
Cap 1 - UE is better. The image has been reformatted to 2.35 which has resulted in very slight cropping.
Cap 2 - UE looks a bit duller, the sky is no longer blue.
Cap 3 - Blue has been changed to aqua, but the result is pleasing enough.
Cap 4 - Not much difference here.
Cap 5 - Again blue has been toned down - they really don't like the blues do they?
Cap 6 - Fair bit sharper upon close inspection.
Worth upgrading to the UE? Not sure to be honest. Maybe when it's half-price?
Posted: 18 Jul 2006, 00:04
by MLAM
bradavon wrote:MLAM: Any of adding a "The World is Not Enough" DVD Comparison please? I can add the UK R2 SE if you like.
When I have time I shall make that my next DVD, no need for providing as I do also have the R2 SE

Posted: 18 Jul 2006, 00:07
by Markgway
We really appreciate your effort, mate.
Posted: 18 Jul 2006, 00:22
by MLAM
It's no real trouble, I'll only compare ones that get requested though for now I think, I may do a few more down the line.
2 more pictures to compare added
Though the pictures may not show it, the old SE DVD is a very poor DVD encoding wise, its consistantly blocky and not a joy to watch at all, by far the worst picture in the SE DVD range I think.
You can see some mild blocking on the Kristina Wayborn capture.
Posted: 18 Jul 2006, 00:27
by bradavon
MLAM wrote:When I have time I shall make that my next DVD, no need for providing as I do also have the R2 SE

Thanks
Markgway wrote:The captions/subs are missing from the UE though, right? I can't remember if they were on the SE as generated text.
Really?
Markgway wrote:Cap 3 - Blue has been changed to aqua, but the result is pleasing enough.
Huh? It looks loads better. The original is so dark, it's much clearer now.
Markgway wrote:Worth upgrading to the UE? Not sure to be honest. Maybe when it's half-price?
Definitely.
I hope I'm making sense my glasses are upstairs

Posted: 18 Jul 2006, 00:29
by Markgway
The Kristina cap is much better on the UE, but I'm not keen on the way they've dulled down some of the images. Look at the lights and the pool on the second last cap.
Posted: 18 Jul 2006, 00:30
by MLAM
bradavon wrote:
Markgway wrote:The captions/subs are missing from the UE though, right? I can't remember if they were on the SE as generated text.
Really?
Yep afraid that is true, the location captions and translations for some indian dialogue were Player Generated on the old R2 SE but they are not on the UE DVD UNLESS YOU TURN ON one of the subtitle streams but that is very annoying.
Posted: 18 Jul 2006, 09:41
by grim_tales
On some caps (like Cap 1) the UE looks much better and sharper but the blue filters on some shots have been removed. Like Mark said, on Cao 2 the sky is less blue.
Posted: 18 Jul 2006, 19:15
by bradavon
Thanks MLAM. Oh dear.
Markgway wrote:Look at the lights and the pool on the second last cap.
At least it looks like a pool now. I've never seen a pool that blue (i.e - SE).
Posted: 23 Jul 2006, 10:38
by James H
The still photographs in "James Bond - The Legacy" would seem to indicate that the pool was as blue as it seemed in the SE...